23 May 2014
Uncommon Commentary #405: When Peaceniks Nix Peace (Alternate Title: Putting the "Fist" in "Pacifist")
One
of the great misconceptions of our time is the idea that leftists oppose
war. The truth is merely that their
motivation for waging wars differs from that of rightists. Rightists tend to be intensely patriotic, and
thus to feel a duty to serve their country under arms even if they disagree
with the reason for the belligerency.
For leftists, by contrast, whether to fight a war or to refuse to do so
is a purely ideological question, the answer thereto depending on whether they
expect their cause to benefit more from war or from peace. Indeed, since some religious sects forbid
their members to kill fellow human beings, and religious persons lean
politically "conservative" rather than "liberal", there
probably are more genuine pacifists on the Right than on the Left.
15 May 2014
Uncommon Commentary #404: Acts 5, Secularists 0
I've
paid more than one visit to an history-and-archaeology w.w.w. site called
Livius.org. Since (the old version of)
said site follows the egregious practice of using
"BCE" and "CE" instead of BC and AD, I can't give it my
wholehearted recommendation, but it does provide an interesting list of
messianic claimants during antiquity.
What interests me the most about the list is the fact that, of the 19
entries, just one was ever acclaimed as messiah even after he died. If the man in
whom you had placed your hopes had just been executed, don't you think that you
would give up on him? What would you
gain (unless you are a masochist who wants to be persecuted and ultimately put
to death) by proclaiming that he had risen from the tomb, if you didn't really
believe that he had done so? Either
Christ's disciples repeatedly experienced the mass hallucination that He
appeared to them, or He did actually appear; if you're a secular fanatic you'll
prefer the former explanation, but, if you're like me, you'll prefer the correct
one. (You may also want to read the
similar opinion expressed by Gamaliel in Acts 5:34-39, which passage mentions
two of the false messiahs.)
09 May 2014
Miscellaneous Musing #63
Having
a capital, a (single) city in which organs of government are concentrated, made sense prior to
the advent of either instantaneous distant communication or weapons of instantaneous mass
destruction. Now that messages between
officials can be received immediately in places thousands of miles from their
origin, however, it's outdated; and now that a single surprise attack with a (nuclear) bomb can annihilate an entire city and thus wipe out all three
branches of the US government at once, it's a liability.
01 May 2014
Uncommon Commentary #403: Ranters v. Rancher
Cliven
Bundy, the Nevada cattle-rancher who has won notoriety through his defiance of
the federal government over allegedly illegal grazing, aroused further furor
with supposedly "racist" comments made about a week back. I haven't really decided whether Bundy or the
Bureau of Land Management is in the right in this dispute (although I do, of course, think that
the BLM used an excessive display of force when it attempted to seize his
herd), but I certainly have something to say about the second controversy. What Bundy said to ignite the firestorm was:
They (Blacks) abort their young children, they put their young men in jail because they never learned how to pick cotton. And, I've often wondered, are they better off as slaves, picking cotton and having a family and doing things, or are they better off under government subsidy.
When
asked on the Peter Schiff Show to clarify his remarks, he said "I'm
wondering are they happier now under this government subsidy system than they
were (when) they were slaves?", and, at a press conference, he said that
he was just posing a "question" about whether Black people are better
off now than in the days of slavery.
If Bundy were
actually saying that Black people are morally inferior to Whites, or advocating the restoration of slavery, then he would deserve
censure (though still not the opprobrium directed at him); Do you honestly think that he was doing that? To me it sounds as though he merely (though artlessly) laments
the high rates of abortion, incarceration, and government assistance among US
Blacks, and questions whether they are truly any better off in these circumstances
than they were before emancipation. I've
heard similar jeremiads from well-known Black leaders, but, since Bundy is
Caucasoid, we who have developed tin ears from having lived with Political
Correctness (or, as I've dubbed it, "Totalitarianism Light") for a
quarter-century hear the words "Black" (or
"African-American") and "slaves" and temporarily discard our
ability to reason; one can see this in the fact that not only left-wing outlets
like Media Matters (which ought to change its name to "Media Matters, but
Logic Doesn't"), but even Republicans who have supported Bundy in his
standoff versus Uncle Sam, like US Senator Rant Paul—I mean, Rand Paul—have inveighed against him by calling his
statement "racist" and "offensive". Such judgmentalism (with an unhealthy dose of
paranoia likely mixed in) is itself offensive, and provides additional evidence
that Big Brother is alive and well in this country, which takes pride in considering
itself the freest in the world from thought control.
26 April 2014
Uncommon Commentary #402: Miscellaneous Musing #54 (and MM #54 Update) Follow-Up
All
the revelations by Edward Snowden embarrass Uncle Sam, but, with just one possible
exception of which I know, they in no way compromise our security. (An
intelligence professional has said that targets of US government surveillance
will change their behavior now that they know that the NSA is snooping on
their, and everyone else's, electronic mails and telephone calls and so
forth.) The man is technically guilty of
betraying a trust, but to speak of him as if he belonged in the same category
as Julius and Ethel Rosenberg, who stole secrets that facilitated the USSR's acquisition
of atomic weaponry, does more than strain the limits of credulity; it bursts
right through them.
21 April 2014
Uncommon Commentary #401: Cry Me a River, Crimea Peninsula
Since
"Great Russians" (the people whom we simply call "Russians"
today) rather than Ukrainians (known historically as "Little
Russians") have long made up most of the population of both the Crimean
peninsula and the eastern, industrial belt of the Ukraine, it really makes more
sense for these areas to be part of Russia than for them to remain Ukrainian;
indeed, when both Russia (as the Russian Soviet Federated Socialist Republic) and
the Ukraine (as the Ukrainian Soviet Socialist Republic) were components of the
USSR, Crimea was for some time part of the former rather than the latter.
This does not mean, however, that Russia's ongoing expansionism genuinely concerns ethnicity. Since Great Russia made no attempt to absorb any part of Little Russia while the pro-Russian Yanukovych was in power in Kiev, we can safely assume that Vladimir Putin is trying to compensate for the overthrow of his client by carving off as much of the Ukraine as he thinks he can using nationalism as justification; it may be that what we are now seeing is one step in a divide-and-conquer policy that will lead to the swallowing-up of the entire Ukraine, and it may even be, as some have speculated, that the invasion of Georgia in 2008 and the present situation demonstrate an intention on Putin's part to reassemble the Soviet empire.
Nor does it mean that we ought to ignore the current phase of Russia's aggrandizement or to go on pretending that our pathetic sanctions are an adequate response thereto. The dissolution of the USSR left some of that state's atomic weapons within the boundaries of what had become the just-plain-republic of Ukraine; in return for the abolition of those nuclear arms, which the Ukrainians could have used to defend their land against what is currently happening, we promised in 1994 to uphold Ukrainian territorial integrity. This theoretical guarantee justifies taking serious action to oppose Russia's annexation of Crimea and potential further acquisitions; we don't need to conjure hypocritical objections such as the Obombast administration's complaint that the Crimean decision to leave the Ukraine was not "legitimate". (I say "hypocritical" because the Obama Nation is itself a product of a unilateral declaration of independence, which was not preceded by a referendum in which 97 percent of the participants voted for secession. Historians estimate that a mere third of the denizens of the Thirteen Colonies favored the independence movement.)
Confrontation with Russia therefore is diplomatically obligatory, but it seems to require more nerve than even so egotistical a man as Obama has; perhaps that's why he has referred to himself as a "community organizer" and not as an "international community" organizer.
This does not mean, however, that Russia's ongoing expansionism genuinely concerns ethnicity. Since Great Russia made no attempt to absorb any part of Little Russia while the pro-Russian Yanukovych was in power in Kiev, we can safely assume that Vladimir Putin is trying to compensate for the overthrow of his client by carving off as much of the Ukraine as he thinks he can using nationalism as justification; it may be that what we are now seeing is one step in a divide-and-conquer policy that will lead to the swallowing-up of the entire Ukraine, and it may even be, as some have speculated, that the invasion of Georgia in 2008 and the present situation demonstrate an intention on Putin's part to reassemble the Soviet empire.
Nor does it mean that we ought to ignore the current phase of Russia's aggrandizement or to go on pretending that our pathetic sanctions are an adequate response thereto. The dissolution of the USSR left some of that state's atomic weapons within the boundaries of what had become the just-plain-republic of Ukraine; in return for the abolition of those nuclear arms, which the Ukrainians could have used to defend their land against what is currently happening, we promised in 1994 to uphold Ukrainian territorial integrity. This theoretical guarantee justifies taking serious action to oppose Russia's annexation of Crimea and potential further acquisitions; we don't need to conjure hypocritical objections such as the Obombast administration's complaint that the Crimean decision to leave the Ukraine was not "legitimate". (I say "hypocritical" because the Obama Nation is itself a product of a unilateral declaration of independence, which was not preceded by a referendum in which 97 percent of the participants voted for secession. Historians estimate that a mere third of the denizens of the Thirteen Colonies favored the independence movement.)
Confrontation with Russia therefore is diplomatically obligatory, but it seems to require more nerve than even so egotistical a man as Obama has; perhaps that's why he has referred to himself as a "community organizer" and not as an "international community" organizer.
13 April 2014
Uncommon Commentary #400!: And Since it's Not Made of Cheese Like the Moon, There's Nothing to Eat
Attempting
to colonize Mars is a deplorable idea.
The Red Planet is almost completely unsuitable for human habitation, and
there's really no reason to try to make it more suitable by, as has been
proposed, monkeying with the atmosphere for the sake of engineering an
"intentional greenhouse effect", because our own planet is generally far
from crowded; the problem here is not one of excessive population but of
extremely uneven distribution of that population. Before we risk repeating elsewhere in the
cosmos the same mistakes that we've made on our own world, let's put better
effort into correcting what's gone wrong on Earth.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)