18 February 2013
Uncommon Commentary #324: The Poor Estate of the Fourth Estate
It's widely recognized in
"conservative" circles that the pervasiveness of left-wing bias in
the mainstream US media, including what passes for a free press, is a serious
liability for our country; it probably gave Obama the presidency in 2008, and
almost unquestionably did so in 2012. I
have never, however, heard anyone suggest a remedy for this ill, and so here's
my proposal. Let the news corps continue
independently, but require journalists to have licensing from an equally
independent, respected third party (i.e., "watchdog", a word that is
much overused in this sense); the government would authorize this third party
to examine and correct the news media for bias and inaccuracy. One needs a license to practice law or
medicine, or to be a public-school teacher or a private investigator (or even
to marry someone or to drive a car), and so why not apply the same standard to
journalism? (Under my system, however, newsmen would be held to a much higher standard than, for example, the
public-school teachers generally are.)
In fact, this system of licensing could be applied to much more than
journalism, even becoming the USA's new way of doing things: a middle ground
between the statism demanded by leftists and the so-called-conservatives' endurance
in perpetual exasperation over such grave problems as the one that I've
discussed in this uncommon commentary.
Many would indubitably regard this as "government overreach",
but who has a better idea?