30 November 2015
[Monday's] Miscellaneous Musing [#76]: Mongol Marauders Made Mayhem
Among the many things that irk me is hearing someone speak as if there had
been such a thing as a Mongol “empire”. Temujin
(the man known to history by the title “Genghis Khan”) and his successors conquered
immense territories, but the Mongols, being nomadic barbarians, had neither the
willingness nor the ability to rule
what they conquered; they merely exacted tribute from defeated peoples, by threatening
to return and do something even worse than what they had done previously. Their system was highly effective for a rather
long time, but it was not imperialism; it was banditry on a national scale.
(Temujin’s descendant Kublai Khan did rule an empire, but it was not a Mongol
empire; it was a Chinese empire with a Mongol dynasty.) I have seen some
historical maps in which tributary states are included in other “empires” such
as the hegemony established by the Guptas over much of India, and the word “empire”
is often used very loosely; to talk of a Mongol “empire”, though, which gives
the impression that the Mongols not merely enjoyed ascendancy but actually controlled a realm stretching from Eastern
Europe to Korea, is, in my opinion, to use that word much more loosely than it
ought to be used.